Foolproof Instant Pot Yogurt – Only 2 Ingredients

Instant Pot yogurt is surprisingly easy to make with just 2 ingredients and not a whole lot of hands-on time, plus it's healthier and cheaper!

Prep10 min
Cook8 hr
Total8 hr 10 min
Serves16 cups

Published 9 Apr 2020

Jump to recipe

Instant Pot yogurtis surprisingly easy to make with just 2 ingredients and not a whole lot of hands-on time! This foolproof method makes homemade yogurt that’s healthier, more affordable, and much more customizable than store-bought options. If you love yogurt like we do, this is a great way to make a big batch of it at a way lower cost.

These 5 quick, simple, and healthy yogurt bowl ideas are packed with nutrition and will help you get excited about eating a healthy breakfast (or snack!).

My 2 Best Tips For Making Instant Pot Yogurt

Use A Good Yogurt Starter:Any plain store-bought yogurt will work as your starter as long as it contains active bacterial cultures. Check the label for ingredients like Lactobacillus bulgaricus or Streptococcus thermophilus. Never use flavored yogurt as your starter! After making your first batch, you can save a few tablespoons in the freezer to use as starter for your next batch.

Perfect Milk Temperature:For successful yogurt, milk must be heated to the right temperature (around 180°F) and then cooled to the proper culturing temperature (about 110°F) before adding your starter. Aninstant-read thermometeris invaluable for this process. If you don’t bring the milk to the right temperature initially, the yogurt might not set properly.

🩷

This is SUCHan easy recipeand you only need three things: milk, a couple tablespoons of plain yogurt with live and active cultures, and an Instant Pot!

Store-bought yogurt can be pricey, especially if you get it all the time and use it almost daily like we do.

Whether you love yogurt in parfaits, fruit salad,smoothies, as a sour cream substitute, or any other way, this recipe yields a big batch for a lot lower price than buying yogurt in bulk from the grocery store!

The amazing thing is that your Instant Pot has a yogurt setting, and all you have to do is add milk and yogurt to the pot, turn on the yogurt setting, and let it do its thing for 8 hours.

Recipe Ingredients

Milk:Whole milk makes the thickest and creamiest yogurt in my opinion, but you can also use 2% or skim.
Plain yogurt with live and active cultures:The live, active cultures are important because these are what mix with the milk to turn it into yogurt!

See the recipe card below for full information on ingredients and quantities.

Homemade Yogurt Variations

Low-fat:Use low-fat or skim milk to make low-fat yogurt.

Sweet:Stir in 2 to 3 tablespoons honey or brown sugar after the yogurt is done in the Instant Pot for sweet yogurt.

Vanilla:Add 2 teaspoons vanilla to the yogurt once it’s done in the Instant Pot.

five round white bowls filled with instant pot yogurt and fruits nuts and granola

Recipe FAQs

What kind of milk works best for Instant Pot yogurt?

You have many options when it comes to milk for your homemade yogurt! Whole milk yields the thickest and creamiest results, but you can also use 2% or skim milk with good results. If using lower-fat milk, you may want to add some nonfat dry milk powder to help thicken the final product. Some people successfully make yogurt with lactose-free milk as well. The higher the fat content, the creamier and thicker your yogurt will be.

What yogurt starter should I use?

Any plain store-bought yogurt will work as your starter as long as it contains active bacterial cultures. Check the label for ingredients like Lactobacillus bulgaricus or Streptococcus thermophilus. Never use flavored yogurt as your starter! After making your first batch, you can save a few tablespoons in the freezer to use as starter for your next batch.

Why do I need to remove the rubber ring from the Instant Pot lid?

The silicone ring on the Instant Pot lid tends to absorb odors from previous cooking. If you don’t remove it, your yogurt might end up tasting like the last thing you cooked, such as chili or curry! Since you don’t need pressure for making yogurt, it’s perfectly fine to use the lid without the ring. **I actually bought the same lid with the silicone ring for my Instant Pot at a yard sale and since it didn’t have the strong smells from cooking (like mine does!), I save it for using only on things like yogurt and sweet things to keep out the smell!

How do I make yogurt in an Instant Pot without a yogurt setting?

If your Instant Pot does not have a yogurt button, here’s how to make it:Pour the milk into inner pot of pressure cooker. Turn on the Sear/Sauté button. Heat milk to 180°F, and use a thermometer to check the temperature often. Be sure to stir very often so milk does not scorch. Once the milk reaches 180°F, turn off the pressure cooker. Remove inner pot and cool to 110° F, and then whisk in the yogurt until incorporated. Put inner pot back into the pressure cooker and add the lid. Wrap in a large towel, or two regular towels, and incubate for 8 hours.

How do I store homemade yogurt?

Store homemade yogurt in covered containers in the fridge for 7-10 days. (I use mason jars.) Reserve 3 tablespoons, which can be frozen, to make your next batch.

Fabulous Recipes Using Homemade Yogurt

Other Yummy Breakfast Recipes To Try

Did you make this recipe? Leave a⭐️review and share it onInstagram,Facebook, orPinterest!

Instant Pot Yogurt

Instant Pot yogurt is surprisingly easy to make with just 2 ingredients and not a whole lot of hands-on time! This foolproof method makes homemade yogurt that's healthier, more affordable, and much more customizable than store-bought options. If you love yogurt like we do, this is a great way to make a big batch of it at a way lower cost.

Ingredients

1 gallon milk
3 tablespoons plain yogurt with live and active cultures

Instructions

To prep your Instant Pot, remove the rubber ring on the underside of the lid. For lots of people, this rubber ring smells like all of the things that you cook (mine smells like chili), and we don't want yogurt that tastes like chili. Remove the ring and wash the lid and metal insert/bowl well.
Dry all the pieces well, and put the bowl back into the Instant Pot.
Add the milk.
Stir in your plain yogurt.
Add the lid (you don't need the rubber ring, you aren't pressure cooking the yogurt; the lid doesn't need that to seal for this).
Note for First Time: The first time using your Instant Pot to make yogurt, you may want to check the temperature after 1-2 hours to see if it reads 110-115° F. If it has not reached this temperature range, press cancel and then press the yogurt button until it says "boil." Keep checking the temp with the digital thermometer and press cancel when it reaches 110°. Then resume the warming setting by pushing the yogurt button and choosing the amount of time. You will only need to do this the first time and then you'll know if your Instant Pot gets the milk up to the perfect temperature just by pressing the yogurt button or if you need to help it along by using the boil setting first.
Press the yogurt button and select "low" (just press the yogurt button a few times until the light that indicates the amount of pressure says low).
Select the time that you'd like it to run. (The default is 8 hours, but it can keep the yogurt warm as long as 24. The yogurt will be as set as it's going to be at 8 hours and will get more tart with more time, not thicker.)
Leave the Instant Pot alone for the amount of time you chose.
When the time is up, remove the lid and you have yogurt!
If you'd like it thicker, you can strain the yogurt. I like to strain it. You can use a yogurt strainer (like this one), or line a colander with 3 layers of cheese cloth and set it in a large bowl. Let it strain for 2 to 3 hours depending on how thick you'd like it.
Place the strained yogurt in the fridge (I keep mine in mason jars).
Reserve a few tablespoons of your homemade yogurt to make your next batch.

Notes

Milk Choices: You have LOTS of options when it comes to milk. Whole milk yields the thickest and creamiest yogurt. You can make it with 2% and skim milk. I know people also have success using lactose free milk. Raw Milk Use: If your milk is not pasteurized, you can boil it before using. Just be sure to bring it down in temperature to no higher than 110 degrees F. before adding your yogurt to the milk. Homemade Greek Yogurt: If you'd like it thicker, strain it in a yogurt strainer or line a colander with 3 layers of cheese cloth and set it in a large bowl. Let it strain for 2 to 3 hours depending on how thick you'd like it. For Instant Pots Without Yogurt Function: If your Instant Pot does not have a yogurt button, here's how to make it: Pour the milk into inner pot of pressure cooker. Turn on the Sear/Sauté button. Heat milk to 180°F, and use a thermometer to check the temperature often. Be sure to stir very often so milk does not scorch. Once the milk reaches 180°F, turn off the pressure cooker. Remove inner pot and cool to 110° F, and then whisk in the yogurt until incorporated. Put inner pot back into the pressure cooker and add the lid. Wrap in a large towel, or two regular towels, and incubate for 8 hours. Slow Cooker Option: You can also make yogurt in your slow cooker! Here's my tutorial on slow cooker yogurt. Yummy Uses For Homemade Yogurt: Sweet Fresh berries or other fruits Honey or maple syrup Homemade jam or preserves Vanilla extract and a sprinkle of cinnamon Granola and a drizzle of honey Savory Use as a sour cream substitute in tacos or baked potatoes Make tzatziki sauce with cucumber, garlic, and dill Create creamy salad dressings Use in marinades for tender, flavorful meat